Book Review: Mrs. Jeffries & The Feast Of St. Stephen

by Emily Brightwell

Berkeley Publishing Group, 2007

My sister has been telling me about the Mrs. Jeffries mystery series that she has been enjoying for a while. Kaye gave me book number twenty-three in this twenty-seven-book series to see what I thought.

I know what you are thinking: twenty-seven is a lot of books and to start a series at number twenty-three is crazy. That’s probably true but let me assure you that this particular book, at least, stands alone quite nicely. The author did a superb job of letting me know who’s who without making it seem like she was repeating herself. Let me tell you what the story is about.

The series, set in England in the late 1800s, centers around Inspector Witherspoon and his household of servants. The Inspector has become known for solving tough murder mysteries but it’s actually his household staff plus assorted frieds working behind the scenes who snoop out most of the details of the crime.

Mrs. Jeffries is the housekeeper and she’s the master of organization as well as detection. For background information on victims and suspects, Mrs. Jeffries relies on the elderly cook who has an extensive network of delivery men, vendors and others.

The maid, the footman, and the coachmen are skilled at getting information out of various sources. They’ve also learned to follow people without being seen. There is also Constable Barnes who helps the Inspector with the official police business. Doctor Boswell is a police surgeon on good terms with the household and he shares his information. Together they are all a good team.

In this particular book, The Feast of St. Stephen, a rich gentleman has been poisoned during a dinner party. It looks like the poison was in a bottle of wine brought by two of the guests. But any of the other five guests and members of the rich man’s staff could have slipped the foxglove into the wine.

The story moves nicely through all the gossip and little clues surrounding the victim and the numerous suspects. It turns out the Inspector is not a bumbling comic figure at all. He can manage himself quite well. He sees to be very good at interviewing suspects. He’s just not that good at the detecting part of the job. But that’s okay because he has plenty of help. It is Mrs. Jeffries who guides the inspector toward the final solution.

The books are billed as “Mrs. Jeffries is the Miss Marple of Victorian Mystery.” My sister (also a big Agatha Christie fan) and I agree that this book has the same sort of homey feeling you’ll find in a Miss Marple story. It’s that understanding of village life and the behavior of people that we find so appealing. I like the way Mrs. Jeffries manages the case and orgnizes her little band of detectives and then subtly maneuvers the Inspector. I will definitely read another book in this series, although probably not all twenty-seven.

I was curious about the author, Emily Brightwell. It turns out she is really Cheryl Arguile who lives in Orange County, California. That’s the same area in which my sister lives. The author has dabbled in romances and young adult novels but none are in print right now. If you are interested, her website is here.

Thanks to my sister Kaye for urging me to read this one. Most of the books are available at the library. This one is available also at Amazon. (I am an Amazon Associate.)

Has anyone else read this series?

This entry was posted in 100+ Book Challenge, Book Challenges, Books, Cozy Mysteries and tagged , . Bookmark the permalink.

14 Responses to Book Review: Mrs. Jeffries & The Feast Of St. Stephen

  1. Molly says:

    I have not read this series – yet – but I did manage to find the first book (which I would have to read first, you know) at Half Price and bought it to read “some day” in the probably distant future.

    I am glad that you enjoyed it and look forward to your review of others in the series.

  2. Barbara says:

    This book sounds charming. For some reason I like books where the “help” manages to maneuver the master or mistress of the house, for a good purpose of course. 🙂

  3. Staci says:

    I haven’t read this series..yet! I loved your review so much that I want to read at least one from this author. I’ve yet to read a Miss Marple book too!

  4. Kay says:

    I’m so glad to hear your reactions to a Mrs. Jeffries mystery, Margot. I have an omnibus (isn’t that the word) of the first 2 or 3 of this series around here somewhere. I bought it a while back and meant to start reading. I’ll have to find it and see what I think. Any Miss Marple comparison and I’m so there. 🙂

  5. Looks like a fun and different series; I’ve gotten so burned out on most cozy mystery series that I used to really enjoy. And so (thanks to you) I’m reading mostly Agatha Christie now for my “in-between” books (I try to read something more challenging in between the fun stuff — don’t always succeed).

  6. By the way, do you have a link where I can get a list of all the Agatha Christie books?

  7. stacybuckeye says:

    Interesting that a Califirnia gal can capture the old English villages so well! I’ve deen this series, but haven’t tried one. I applaud you for being willing to start with #23 🙂

  8. Bumbles says:

    Reminds me of the old cartoon Hong Kong Phooey where he got all the credit but it was really the cat who always saved the day ;0)

  9. I bet my mother would love this series!

  10. caite says:

    27 in a series is quite a series…

  11. kaye says:

    they sound good . . .

  12. Beth F says:

    I’ve heard of this series but never read them. If I had known more about the books I might have picked them up sooner. I’ll add them to my wish list.

  13. Kaye,the sister, Cogdill says:

    Hey Margot…your write-up on “Mrs. Jeffries” truly captures its essence!! I hope you have many positive responses! If either of us has time for another in the series, we will share! Love ya bunches, Kaye

  14. Diana says:

    I have fallen in love with this series. I have not enjoyed anything this much since reading Agatha Christie. I would recommend it to anyone.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *